Alienation (New Directions in Critical Theory)

By Rahel Jaeggi

The Hegelian-Marxist inspiration of alienation fell out of fashion after the postmetaphysical rejection of humanism and essentialist perspectives of human nature. during this ebook Rahel Jaeggi attracts at the Hegelian philosophical culture, phenomenological analyses grounded in sleek conceptions of employer, and up to date paintings within the analytical culture to reconceive alienation because the absence of a significant courting to oneself and others, which manifests in emotions of helplessness and the despondent recognition of ossified social roles and expectations.

A revived method of alienation is helping severe social concept interact with phenomena corresponding to meaninglessness, isolation, and indifference. by means of severing alienation's hyperlink to a problematical perception of human essence whereas holding its social-philosophical content material, Jaeggi offers assets for a renewed critique of social pathologies, a much-neglected obstacle in modern liberal political philosophy. Her paintings revisits the arguments of Rousseau, Hegel, Kierkegaard, and Heidegger, putting them in discussion with Thomas Nagel, Bernard Williams, and Charles Taylor.

Show description

Quick preview of Alienation (New Directions in Critical Theory) PDF

Best Political Theory books

The Rehnquist Court and the Constitution

Within the Rehnquist court docket and the structure, Tinsley Yarbrough offers a accomplished examine modern superb courtroom Justices and their record--a learn all of the extra priceless for the Court's combined judgements and hard-to-categorize direction. An finished biographer, Yarbrough deals incisive graphics of the 9 who now sit down at the excessive bench, and tellingly stories their nomination hearings.

Just Marriage (New Democracy Forum)

From the floor breaking criminal judgements on homosexual marriage to the promoting of marriage for low-income households, the "sacred establishment" of marriage has became a public battleground. Who might be allowed to marry and is marriage a public or deepest act? may still marriage be deserted thoroughly? Or should still marriage be redefined as a civil establishment that promotes sexual and racial equality?

The Multiculturalism of Fear

This very important new liberal account of multiculturalism combines an research of the coverage dilemmas confronted by means of multiethnic states all over the world with a philosophical attention of multiculturalism and nationalism. Jacob T. Levy boldly argues that liberalism shouldn't be centrally excited about both holding or transcending cultural groups, practices, and identities.

Rousseau's Theodicy of Self-Love: Evil, Rationality, and the Drive for Recognition

This e-book is the 1st finished learn of Rousseau's wealthy and complicated thought of the kind of self-love (amour propre ) that, for him, marks the significant distinction among people and the beasts. Amour propre is the eagerness that drives human members to hunt the esteem, approval, admiration, or love--the acceptance --of their fellow beings.

Additional resources for Alienation (New Directions in Critical Theory)

Show sample text content

Among DECISIONISM AND THE center version it's instructive to work out why Frankfurt can't remedy this challenge in the framework of his version. Frankfurt is still not sure among opposing versions of rationalization, which, translated into Heideggerian terminology, you'll be able to symbolize as resoluteness and thrownness. the 1st emphasizes the lively parts of the identity strategy (making decisions), while the second one emphasizes the passive (fateful) components. either types, even if, run into problems: the 1st can't justify the authority of wants; the second one falls again into an essentialism that makes it most unlikely to trap aspirations for self-transformation and emancipation as they seem in our protagonist’s preliminary emotions of alienation. (a) Resoluteness. occasionally (in the essay we have now mentioned) Frankfurt characterizes the method of identity within which one pertains to one’s personal wishes and passions as a type of choice with a essentially lively personality: “it seems to be by way of creating a specific type of choice that the relation of the individual to his passions is tested. ”22 despite the fact that, Frankfurt has a tough time characterizing the explicit nature of this type of selection such that it has the binding strength and necessity it's speculated to have: “In any occasion, the character of determination is especially vague. ”23 There are reliable purposes for this hassle. As defined above, the authorization of wishes can't be a only voluntaristic procedure. the choice in query has to be made up our minds by way of whatever that—in a manner that's certainly tough to grasp—comes from a “deeper,” “weightier,” or greater based stance. one more aspect is usually an important for my approach of posing the query: the resoluteness version can't fairly clarify the potential for self-alienation because it seems in our case. If identity is conceived of decisionistically—if we make our wants our personal through an easy decision—it is feasible to fall right into a situation of irresoluteness that threatens our identification. This dissolution of identification, despite the fact that, isn't really reminiscent of self-alienation. in response to this version, each choice (as lengthy because it is satisfactorily enterprise) ends up in an “agreement with self” that can't be extra puzzled or evaluated. The query “What do i actually wish? ” is then not significant. it might refer in simple terms to the depth or resoluteness with which one wills. The query “Am i actually resolute? ” can't be meaningfully posed or, at most sensible, simply rhetorically. the matter of a desire’s authority within the feel of its legitimacy has no position right here. utilized to H. , who questions her identity together with her moment order volition for emancipation: within the decisionist model of Frankfurt’s place the matter can't be posed such that there can be a right resolution to the query of what she may still determine with. From this attitude the one challenge is that she asks this query in any respect, that she isn't really sufficiently resolute in leaning towards one among her wants. She can't fail to be herself in figuring out for one part or the opposite; her identification is threatened only through the truth that she is not sure.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.54 of 5 – based on 18 votes