Framing a Legend: Exposing the Distorted History of Thomas Jefferson and Sally Hemings

A penetrating serious point of view at the query of Thomas Jefferson's paternity that might make you reconsider fresh traditional wisdom.

It is authorized by way of such a lot students that Jefferson had a long affair along with his slave Sally Hemings and fathered at the very least one in all her teenagers, a end in response to a 1998 DNA research released in Nature and at the paintings of historian Annette Gordon-Reed. Framing a Legend argues compellingly that the DNA facts is inconclusive and that there are impressive flaws within the top historic scholarship purporting to teach this sort of liaison.

Author M. Andrew Holowchak critically examines recognized books by way of Fawn Brodie, Annette Gordon-Reed, and Andrew Burstein, labeling their perspectives as "three admired spins." He then delves into what we all know approximately Thomas Jefferson's personality, exhibiting that the historic proof don't recommend any romantic curiosity on Jefferson's half in his girl slaves. Turning to the genetic proof, Holowchak issues out that, even though DNA research exhibits the presence of a Y-chromosome from a few Jefferson male within the Hemings kin line, it's unwarranted to finish that this should have come from Thomas Jefferson.

Finally, he discusses Jefferson's racial attitudes and says that they argue opposed to any liaison with Sally Hemings.

Show description

Quick preview of Framing a Legend: Exposing the Distorted History of Thomas Jefferson and Sally Hemings PDF

Best American History books

Hetty: The Genius and Madness of America's First Female Tycoon

Whilst J. P. Morgan known as a gathering of latest York's monetary leaders after the inventory marketplace crash of 1907, Hetty eco-friendly used to be the one lady within the room. The Guinness ebook of worldwide documents memorialized her because the World's maximum Miser, and, certainly, this not likely robber baron -- who parlayed a comfy inheritance right into a fortune that was once worthy approximately 1.

I Love Paul Revere, Whether He Rode or Not

In the end in paperback, Richard Shenkman's bestselling sequel to Legends, Lies & adored Myths of yank historical past. Provocative and amusingly heretical, "I Love Paul Revere, no matter if He Rode or Not" (a quote attributed to Warren Harding) deals eye-opening revelations debunking long-held American legends.

The Battle of New Orleans: Andrew Jackson and America's First Military Victory

The conflict of latest Orleans was once the climactic conflict of America's "forgotten warfare" of 1812. Andrew Jackson led his ragtag corps of infantrymen opposed to 8,000 disciplined invading British regulars in a conflict that introduced the British a humiliating army defeat. The victory solidified America's independence and marked the start of Jackson's upward thrust to nationwide prominence.

The American President: From Teddy Roosevelt to Bill Clinton

The yankee President is a charming account of yank presidential activities from the assassination of William McKinley in 1901 to invoice Clinton's final evening in place of work in January 2001. William Leuchtenburg, one of many nice presidential historians of the century, portrays all the presidents in a chronicle gleaming with anecdote and wit.

Extra info for Framing a Legend: Exposing the Distorted History of Thomas Jefferson and Sally Hemings

Show sample text content

In addition, Jefferson famous that liberty got here with a price—service to one's state. even though he expressed on a number of events his desire to retire from public provider and spend his time with kin at Monticello,66 he had spent his salad years in provider to the yank country. notwithstanding he famous, as did the Roman Stoic Seneca, that you can ask in basic terms rather a lot of somebody, that sooner or later it was once time for others to do their half, he said that you could nonetheless modestly serve one's kingdom in retirement. sixty seven He greater than modestly served his nation in retirement. He used to be a dutiful letter writer—an vital carrier to his fellow voters in addition to his human beings—and virtually day-by-day oversaw building of his puppy venture in retirement—the college of Virginia. even if obviously “anal,” he confirmed superordinary adjustment to reality—a convinced indication that he used to be no longer somebody bedazzled via libidinal distractions. BRODIE'S “INVESTIGATIVE” strategies Psychologizing Brodie's paintings has been roundly criticized by way of historians for its conclusions, in line with flights of fancy: innuendo and never truth. Sally Hemings, a minor ancient determine approximately whom not anything is unquestionably recognized, turns into in her crafty, Machiavellian mind's eye an important historic determine who had a marked impression on overdue eighteenth-century and early nineteenth-century happenings via a thirty-eight-year dating with Thomas Jefferson. Historian John C. Miller within the Wolf via the Ears writes that Brodie is “piling implausibility upon implausibility. ”68 different students agree. Clifford Egan writes, “To Brodie's genuine error, contradictions and cavalier use of facts has to be additional one other sin—the injection of up to date matters into comparing the past”69—what I name in bankruptcy 2 the “fallacy of ancient anachronism. ” Holman Hamilton says, “The publication comprises many blunders of truth or of judgment related to a large old spectrum. ” it's “long on hypothesis and recommendation” and displays Brodie's persisted “strainings for the conjectural. ”70 Garry Wills notes Brodie's ingenuity in addition to her lack of knowledge. “She has controlled to put in writing a protracted and complicated learn of Jefferson with out showing any acquaintance with eighteenth century plantation stipulations, political idea, literary conventions, or medical different types. ”71 William G. Hyland Jr. writes: In Brodie's enthusiasm to discover a hyperlink among Jefferson and Hemings, she misinterpret language and invoked pseudo-psychological factors to over interpret subconscious styles in Jefferson's writing. Brodie wove a story of mental interpretation dependent upon chosen letters written by way of Jefferson. notwithstanding her booklet bought negative experiences from historians for its eccentric mental ruminations, its allegations of deceit of a Founding Father made it a bestseller. seventy two Brodie has additionally been criticized seriously due to her Freudian bent. Jefferson biographer Merrill Peterson dismisses the psychologizing and says the ebook leaves us as ignorant as we begun.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.93 of 5 – based on 28 votes