The Province of Legislation Determined: Legal Theory in Eighteenth-Century Britain (Ideas in Context)

By David Lieberman

A accomplished account of English criminal concept within the age of Blackstone and Bentham for almost a century, The Province of laws made up our minds advances an formidable reinterpretation of eighteenth-century attitudes to social switch and legislation reform. Professor Lieberman's daring synthesis rests on a large survey of felony fabrics and on an in depth dialogue of Blackstone's Commentaries, the jurisprudence of Lord Kames and the Scottish Enlightenment, the manager justiceship of Lord Mansfield, the penal theories of Eden and Romilly, and the legislative technological know-how of Jeremy Bentham. The examine relates felony advancements to the wider cloth of eighteenth-century social and political concept, and gives a singular evaluation of the nature of the typical legislations culture and of Bentham's contribution to the ideology of reform.

Show description

Preview of The Province of Legislation Determined: Legal Theory in Eighteenth-Century Britain (Ideas in Context) PDF

Similar Political Theory books

The Rehnquist Court and the Constitution

Within the Rehnquist court docket and the structure, Tinsley Yarbrough presents a accomplished examine brand new preferrred court docket Justices and their record--a examine all of the extra worthwhile for the Court's combined judgements and hard-to-categorize path. An complete biographer, Yarbrough deals incisive pix of the 9 who now sit down at the excessive bench, and tellingly reports their nomination hearings.

Just Marriage (New Democracy Forum)

From the floor breaking criminal judgements on homosexual marriage to the merchandising of marriage for low-income households, the "sacred establishment" of marriage has become a public battleground. Who can be allowed to marry and is marriage a public or deepest act? should still marriage be deserted thoroughly? Or should still marriage be redefined as a civil establishment that promotes sexual and racial equality?

The Multiculturalism of Fear

This important new liberal account of multiculturalism combines an research of the coverage dilemmas confronted by means of multiethnic states world wide with a philosophical attention of multiculturalism and nationalism. Jacob T. Levy boldly argues that liberalism shouldn't be centrally occupied with both retaining or transcending cultural groups, practices, and identities.

Rousseau's Theodicy of Self-Love: Evil, Rationality, and the Drive for Recognition

This ebook is the 1st finished research of Rousseau's wealthy and intricate conception of the kind of self-love (amour propre ) that, for him, marks the valuable distinction among people and the beasts. Amour propre is the fervour that drives human contributors to hunt the esteem, approval, admiration, or love--the acceptance --of their fellow beings.

Additional resources for The Province of Legislation Determined: Legal Theory in Eighteenth-Century Britain (Ideas in Context)

Show sample text content

Baby, New Discourse of alternate, pp. 113-15. 102 The judiciary visual appeal in King's Bench, the typical legislations had without doubt more advantageous its checklist in dealing with advertisement disputes. The "law-merchant" was once more and more followed in judicial rulings, and judges extra on a regular basis appealed to expert testimony to steer the courts' interpretation of technical tools and records. baby, for instance, had regarded to parliament to redress the criminal wishes of the mercantile neighborhood via statute. Writing in 1757 on debts of alternate, Postlethwayt argued the other case. "In issues of law," he saw, " Westminster corridor should... regulate St Stephen's Chapel" His reasoning, in addition, indicated that the typical legal professionals weren't the single staff to have grown suspicious of the possibility of reform via legislative enactment. "The statutes," he defined, "which don't continuously quadrate with the feel and spirit of the legislations, might subvert a very good a part of it, and render all of the pronounced instances lifeless to posterity... wherein we must always haven't any legislation definite in any respect. " eleven hence, the service provider group might count on extra felony uncertainty from parliamentary acts than from the more and more settled trend of universal legislation judgements. regardless of such facts of development, it might be incorrect to believe that the issues raised via baby and Cary had turn into inappropriate through 1756 whilst Mansfield was once appointed to the Bench. Postlethwayt, no matter what his self assurance in Westminster corridor over Parliament, used to be nonetheless advocating the construction of autonomous service provider courts in 1755, enlisting the testimony of Cary, baby and Defoe, and drawing upon the fascinating "experience" of "other international locations. "12 Even in these parts just like the legislation regulating money owed of alternate, the place the best consolidation had happened, there has been little to represent a "system of jurisprudence" equivalent to legislations writers eagerly discerned in Mansfield's later judgments. the typical legislations courts, regardless of the elevated availability in England of systematic treatises at the " lawmerchant," nonetheless often decided mercantile explanations by means of directing a standard jury to make a decision the problem in response to the person condition of every case. thirteen This strategy, later repudiated by means of Mansfield, had severe barriers. through leaving lots of the choice to show at the specific info of every case, it produced a lot irregularity of selection at the similar issues of legislation. therefore Hardwicke, in a 1734 go well with in regards to the parole attractiveness of a invoice of alternate, was once compelled to comment that "it was once a lot to be needed the eleven 12 thirteen Postlethwayt, Dictionary of exchange, I, 277. lbid. y II, 236-9. See additionally Wynne, Eunomus, I, 12-13. For examples of this method, see E. India Co. v Chitty, (1743) 2 unusual 1175, and Hankey v Trotman, (1746) 1 W Blackstone 1, 1-2. Mansfield and the industrial code courts of Westminster corridor have been extra uniform of their resolutions; specifically in circumstances which take place so usually, and that are of such common situation. " 14 not just did this system fail to serve the needs of criminal sure bet, it may well additionally produce judgements at odds with tested mercantile utilization.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.78 of 5 – based on 21 votes